DIA-HARM: Dialectal Disparities in Harmful Content Detection Across 50 English Dialects

Code

• github.com/jsl5710/dia-harm
  OfficialIn paper★ 0

Abstract

Harmful content detectors, particularly disinformation classifiers, are predominantly developed and evaluated on Standard American English (SAE), leaving their robustness to dialectal variation unexplored. We present DIA-HARM, the first benchmark for evaluating disinformation detection robustness across 50 English dialects spanning U.S., British, African, Caribbean, and Asia-Pacific varieties. Using Multi-VALUE's linguistically grounded transformations, we introduce D-CUBE (Dialectal Disinformation Detection Corpus), a core corpus component of DIA-HARM comprising 195K samples derived from established disinformation benchmarks. Our evaluation of 16 detection models reveals systematic vulnerabilities: human-written dialectal content degrades detection by 1.4-3.6% F1, while AI-generated content remains stable. Fine-tuned transformers substantially outperform zero-shot LLMs (96.6% vs. 78.3% best-case F1), with some models exhibiting catastrophic failures exceeding 33% degradation on mixed content. Cross-dialectal transfer analysis across 2,450 dialect pairs shows that multilingual models (mDeBERTa: 97.2% average F1) generalize effectively, while monolingual models like RoBERTa and XLM-RoBERTa fail on dialectal inputs. These findings demonstrate that current disinformation detectors may systematically disadvantage hundreds of millions of non-SAE speakers worldwide. We release the DIA-HARM benchmark, including the D-CUBE corpus (https://github.com/jsl5710/dia-harm), and evaluation tools (https://jsl5710.github.io/dia-harm).

Reproductions